Projets de recherche - Research Projects
Episteme -
the Epistemology research group in Geneva
My research activities are now integrated in Episteme, the
Epistemology research group of the Department of Philosophy. See Episteme's
webpage.
I am a member of the steering committee of the European Epistemology Network. See the European Epistemology Network webpage.
Perceptual Warrant, Entitlement and A Priori Knowledge
2009 - 2012
Fonds national de la Recherche Scientifique
The FNS project Perceptual Warrant, Entitlement and A Priori Knowledge is funded by the the Swiss National Foundation and based at the Department of Philosophy, University of Geneva. This project adresses the problem of the justification of our perceptual beliefs and of the nature of perceptual evidence. Like most contemporary writers we shall call the generic notion of justification involved warrant. It is usually assumed that classical foundationalism fails for perceptual beliefs, and that a coherence conception justification is equally defective. It is also agreed that the usual divisions between “internalist” conceptions of justification (which requires that one has access to one’s justifications) and “externalist” ones (which do not require access) are inadequate. Recent theories of justification have distanced themselves from both foundationalism and coherentism. On the one hand, some theories have tended to concentrate directly upon the nature of knowledge, by insisting on a condition of “safety” (if one knows that P one could not easily have been wrong). On the other hand some theoeticians have accepted the idea that there can be prima facie, defeasible justification. Our plan is to discuss the application of these approaches to perceptual knowledge.
The project involves Pascal Engel, Ariel Cecchi, Anne Meylan, Katsuya Takahashi, and Julien Dutant.
For further information read the project's full description (.pdf).
Connaissance, raison et normes - Knowledge, reason and norms
1.4.2007 - 2009
Fonds national de la Recherche Scientifique
Research director: Pascal Engel
Project members: Julien Dutant (Assistant and PhD), Anne Meylan (FNS scientific collaborator and PhD student at the University of Neuchâtel), Ariel Cecchi (scientific collaborator).
Summary
The FNS project Knowledge, Reason and Norms aims at bringing together issues in the theory of knowledge and theories of theoretical reasoning and rationality on the one hand and issues in metaethics and in practical rationality on the other hand. It will focus in particular on a confrontation between theories of epistemic justification and theories of practical justification, and between theoretical and practical norms.
It will deal with five main themes :
- a critical examination of the contemporary theories of « virtue epistemology » and of intellectual values,
- an analysis and confrontation between theories of practical reasoning and theoretical reasoning,
- an analysis of doxastic voluntarism and related issues in the philosophy of mind and knowledge,
- an analysis of the « contextualist » approach to knowledge,
- an analysis of the ethics of truth and information in practical ethics.
The aim is to explore the systematic relationships between these themes in order to develop a theory of intellectual values and norms and of their significance for epistemology and ethics (in particular for media ethics).
Events and Seminars
Norms, Values and Rationality (.pdf), Sept 4th 2009. Workshop within the SoPhA conference; with Josée Brunet (Montréal), Daniel Laurier (Montréal), Alan Millar (Stirling), Christian Piller (York), Gianfranco Soldati (Fribourg), Giovanni Tuzet (Milano). Program (.pdf).
Epistemic Emotions, July 14th 2009. Workshop with Jonathan Kvanvig (Baylor), Michael Brady (Glasgow), Ingrid Vendrell Ferran (Swiss Center for Affective Sciences, Geneva), Anita Konzelmann (Basel), and Jerome Dokic (EHESS, Paris). Organised by Anne Meylan with the Thumos group.
New Perspectives on Doxastic Voluntarism, Geneva, June 23rd 2009
Speakers: Josep Corbi (Valencia), Richard Feldman (Rochester), Philipp Nickel (Eindhoven), Erik Olsson (Lund), Daniel Schulthess (Neuchâtel). See the conference page.
Workshop on John Broome, Geneva, May 22nd, 2009
Speakers: John Broome (Oxford), Olav Gjelsvik (Oslo), Sven Ove Hansson (KTH Stockholm) , Andrew Reisner (McGill).
See the conference page.Young European Epistemlogists Workshop, Geneva, march 20-21st 2009
Invited speakers: Adam Carter (Edinburgh), Davide Fassio (Geneva), Mikkel Gerken (Copenhagen), Jan Heylen (Leuven), Chris Kelp (Leuven), Stefan Schubert (Lund). Further speakers TBA. See the conference page.
Workshop: Judgement, Assertion, and Norms, Geneva, dec 4-5, 2008
Speakers: Asbjørn Steglich-Petersen (Aarhus), Timothy Chan (CSMN, Oslo), Igor Douven (Leuven). See the conference page or download the programme.
Epistemic Agency Conference, Geneva, apr 26-27 2008
See the conference's webpage.
Block seminar by John Greco, Geneva, apr 20-27, 2008
Conferences by John Greco (Saint Louis), Geneva, apr 20-27, 2008. (details to be announced)
Norms and Content Conference, Geneva, dec 14, 2007.
Invited speakers: Kathrin Glüer-Pagin (Stockholm), Åsa Wikforss (Stockholm), Ralph Wedgewood (Oxford). (details to be announced)
Philosophical Knowledge Conference, Geneva, nov 20, 2007
Conferences by Jacques Bouveresse (Collège de France), Timothy Williamson (Oxford). Programme and further information here.
Workshop: Prospect for Epistemology in Europe, Geneva, sep 28-29, 2007
Programme here. Invited speakers: Martijn Blaauw (VU Amsterdam), Igor Douven (KU Leuven), Pascal Engel (Geneva), Klemens Kappel (Copenhaguen), Erik Olsson (Lund), Duncan Pritchard (Edinburgh).
Journée Ironique (An Ironical Day), Geneva, may 4th, 2007
Program here (pdf). Invited speakers: Gregory Currie (Nottingham), Sophie Duval (Bordeaux), Patrizia Lombardo (Genève), Kevin Mulligan (Geneva), Anne Reboul (Lyon).
Activities and Conferences
Pascal Engel
Publications
- Book: Pascal Engel, Va Savoir !, Hermann, Paris, 2007.
- Paper: “Des avantages et des inconvénients de faire de la philosophie analytique dans un fauteuil” Melika Ouelbani, ed. La philosophie analytique dans tous ses états, Université de Tunis 2007.
- Paper: « La logique : trois paradoxes », in La philosophie, Eyrolles, 2007.
- Paper: “ Akrasia Pratique et akrasia épistémique ” , Le philosophoire, n°19, “L'Action”, automne 2007.
- Paper: “Making Up Ones Mind”, to appear in J.L. Marion and R. Morrissey (eds.), Le Soi / The Self, Cahiers Parisiens / Parisian Notebooks, No. 3, University of Chicago Press, 2007.
- Paper: “Belief and Normativity”, ms, 2007
- Paper: “Pragmatic Encroachment and Epistemic Value”, ms, 2007.
- Paper: “Davidson on Epistemic Norms”, ms, 2007.
- Review of E.Lepore et K.Ludwig, Davidson's Truth Theoretic Semantics, Notre Dame Reviews in philosophy, sept 2007.
- Review of Bertrand Saint-Sernin, Le rationalisme qui vient, in Revue Philosophique.
- Interview : la Raison, Le philosophoire, juin 2007.
- Interview: "Y a-t-il des degrés de vérité ?" Philo-Magazine, mai 2007.
Conferences and reviews
- Conference "Pragmatic encroachment", University of Notthingham, workshop on Michael Devitt, "What we know and what we don't know about our language", apr 2007
- Conference "Philosophy and psychology", Scuola Estiva, Universita di Firenze, apr 25-27 2007
- Conference "Thought experiments: in or out of the armchair ?", conference "Thought Experiments", Athens, apr 22-24 2007
- Conference "Davidson on epistemic norms", Knowledge, Language, Interpretation: on the Philosophy of Davidson, Universitaddi Genoa, may 25-26.
- Conference "A quoi ressemblerait le carré logique épistémique ?", The Square of Opposition, International Congress, Montreux, june 2, 2007.
- Conference "Can normative explanations be causal ?", Colloque Mental Causation, Université de Lausanne, sept 5, 2007
- Interview : la Raison, Le philosophoire, juin 2007.
- Interview: "Y a-t-il des degrés de vérité ?" Philo-Magazine, mai 2007.
- Review of E.Lepore et K.Ludwig, Davidson's Truth Theoretic Semantics, Notre Dame Reviews in philosophy, sept 2007.
- Review of Bertrand Saint-Sernin, Le rationalisme qui vient, in Revue Philosophique.
Julien Dutant and Anne Meylan
Publications
- Paper: Julien Dutant, "Inexact Knowledge, Margin for Error and Positive Introspection", Proceedings of the XIth TARK conference, Presses Universitaires de Louvain, june 2007.
- Paper: Anne Meylan, "The Value Problem for Knowledge: Against a Reliabilist Solution", Proceedings of the 4th Latin Meeting in Philosophy, Departement of Philosophy, University of Genova, sept 2007.
- Paper: Julien Dutant, "The Case for Infallibilism", Proceedings of the 4th Latin Meeting in Philosophy, Departement of Philosophy, University of Genova, sept 2007.
Conferences
- Conference: Anne Meylan,"Acceptation et contrôle de la croyance dans l'éthique de la croyance contemporaine", international conference Assentiment et volonté, Clermont-Ferrand, may 26-28 2005.
- Conference: Anne Meylan, "Internalisme et conception déontologique de la justification", Colloque des doctorants en philosophie de l'Université de Fribourg, 11 décembre 2006.
- Conference: Anne Meylan, "The Justification of Testimonial Beliefs. The Right to Be Credulous and the Duty to Be Critical", Sequitur (Swiss Philosophy Graduate Association) conference, Bern, apr 1 2006.
- Conference: Anne Meylan, "Actions et croyances : quel contrôle ?", international conference Approches contemporaines de l'action, Grenoble, feb 13 2007.
- Conference Julien Dutant, "Naturaliser les normes et les valeurs épistémiques", 2nd Congress of the Société de Philosophie des Sciences, Geneva, mar 24 2007.
- Conference: Anne Meylan, "William Alston et la conception déontologique de la justification", Research colloquium, Archives Poincaré, Nancy, 13 avril 2007.
- Conference Julien Dutant, "The Limited Gradability of "knows"", International Conference in Linguistics and Epistemology, Aberdeen, may 2007.
- Conference Julien Dutant, "The Margin for Error Principle Revised", Joint Session of the Mind Association and the Aristotelian Society (Open Sessions), Bristol, july 2007.
- Conference Julien Dutant and Anne Meylan, "Is D-I-Y Belief Always Better?", Value of Knowledge conference, Amsterdam, aug 2007.
- Conference: Olivier Massin and Anne Meylan, "The Hedonic Value of Knowledge", Graduate Conference on Knowledge and Understanding, University of Edinburgh, November 13 2007.