This work illustrates a simple approach for optimizing long-lived near-infrared lanthanide-centered luminescence using trivalent chromium chromophores as sensitizers. Reactions of the segmental ligand L2 with stoichiometric amounts of M(CF₃SO₃)₂ (M = Cr, Zn) and Ln(CF₃SO₃)₃ (Ln = Nd, Er, Yb) under aerobic conditions quantitatively yield the D₃-symmetrical trinuclear [MLnM(L2)₃](CF₃SO₃)_n complexes (M = Zn, n = 7; M = Cr, n = 9), in which the central lanthanide activator is sandwiched between the two transition metal cations. Visible or NIR irradiation of the peripheral Cr(III) chromophores in [CrLnCr(L2)₃]⁹⁺ induces rate-limiting intramolecular intermetallic Cr→Ln energy transfer processes (Ln = Nd, Er, Yb), which eventually produces lanthanide-centered near-infrared (NIR) or IR emission with apparent lifetimes within the millisecond range. As compared to the parent dinuclear complexes [CrLn(L1)₃]⁶⁺, the connection of a second strong-field [CrN₆] sensitizer in [CrLnCr(L2)₃]⁹⁺ significantly enhances the emission intensity without perturbing the kinetic regime. This work opens novel exciting photophysical perspectives via the buildup of non-negligible population densities for the long-lived doubly excited state [Cr*LnCr*(L2)₃]⁹⁺ under reasonable pumping powers.

Due to its extreme kinetic inertness, trivalent chromium, Cr(III), has been rarely combined with labile trivalent lanthanides, Ln(III), to give discrete self-assembled (supra)molecular polynuclear complexes. However, the plethora of accessible metal-centered excited states possessing variable lifetimes and emissive properties, combined with the design of efficient intramolecular Cr(III) ^↔ Ln(III) energy transfer processes open attractive perspectives for programming directional light-conversion within these heterometallic molecules. Efforts made to address this exciting challenge for both light-sensitization and light-upconversion are discussed in this article.

This work illustrates a simple approach for optimizing the lanthanide luminescence in molecular dinuclear lanthanide complexes and identifies a particular multidentate europium complex as the best candidate for further incorporation into polymeric materials. The central phenyl ring in the bis-tridentate model ligands L3–L5, which are substituted with neutral (X = H, L3), electron-withdrawing (X = F, L4), or electron-donating (X = OCH₃, L5) groups, separates the 2,6-bis(benzimidazol-2-yl)pyridine binding units of linear oligomeric multi-tridentate ligand strands that are designed for the complexation of luminescent trivalent lanthanides, Ln(III). Reactions of L3–L5 with [Ln(hfac)₃(diglyme)] (hfac^– is the hexafluoroacetylacetonate anion) produce saturated single-stranded dumbbell-shaped complexes [Ln₂(Lk)(hfac)₆] (k = 3–5), in which the lanthanide ions of the two nine-coordinate neutral [N₃Ln(hfac)₃] units are separated by 12–14 Å. The thermodynamic affinities of [Ln(hfac)₃] for the tridentate binding sites in L3–L5 are average (6.6 ≤ log(β_2,1^Y,Lk) ≤ 8.4) but still result in 15–30% dissociation at millimolar concentrations in acetonitrile. In addition to the empirical solubility trend found in organic solvents (L4 > L3 >> L5), which suggests that the 1,4-difluorophenyl spacer in L4 is preferable, we have developed a novel tool for deciphering the photophysical sensitization processes operating in [Eu₂(Lk)(hfac)₆]. A simple interpretation of the complete set of rate constants characterizing the energy migration mechanisms provides straightforward objective criteria for the selection of [Eu₂(L4)(hfac)₆] as the most promising building block.

The connection of two Cr^III sensitizers around a central Er^III acceptor in a self-assembled cation provides high local metal concentrations that favor efficient nonlinear energy transfer upconversion luminescence (see picture). Upon selective low-energy near-infrared irradiation of Cr^III-centered transitions, 1 displays an unprecedented molecular two-photon upconverted green Er^III-centered emission.

Deviations from statistical binding, that is cooperativity, in self-assembled polynuclear complexes partly result from intermetallic interactions ΔE^M,M, whose magnitudes in solution depend on a balance between electrostatic repulsion and solvation energies. These two factors have been reconciled in a simple point-charge model, which suggests severe and counter-intuitive deviations from predictions based solely on the Coulomb law when considering the variation of ΔE^M,M with metallic charge and intermetallic separation in linear polynuclear helicates. To demonstrate this intriguing behaviour, the ten microscopic interactions that define the thermodynamic formation constants of some twenty-nine homometallic and heterometallic polynuclear triple-stranded helicates obtained from the coordination of the segmental ligands L1-L11 with Zn²⁺ (a spherical d-block cation) and Lu³⁺ (a spherical 4f-block cation), have been extracted by using the site binding model. As predicted, but in contrast with the simplistic coulombic approach, the apparent intramolecular intermetallic interactions in solution are found to be i) more repulsive at long distance (ΔE^Lu,Lu_{1-4 >} ΔE^Lu,Lu_1-2), ii) of larger magnitude when Zn²⁺ replaces Lu³⁺ (ΔE^Zn,Lu_1-2 > ΔE^Lu,Lu_1-2) and iii) attractive between two triply charged cations held at some specific distance (ΔE^Lu,Lu_1-3 < 0). The consequences of these trends are discussed for the design of polynuclear complexes in solution.

The mononuclear Os^II complex [Os( L1)₃](PF₆)₂ ( L1 = 5-methyl(1-methylbenzimidazol-2-yl)pyridine) is an obvious candidate for the design of an inert d-block-based tripodal receptor capable of binding and photosensitizing trivalent lanthanides (Ln^III). It has thus been prepared and its two enantiomeric meridional (Δ-mer and Λ-mer) and facial (rac-fac) isomers have been separated by ion-exchange chromatography. The optical isomers have been characterized by CD spectroscopy and assignments of absolute configuration confirmed by an X-ray crystallographic study of Λ-mer-[Os( L1)₃](PF₆)₂·1.5MeCN (monoclinic, P2₁, Z = 4). Comparison of the latter structure with that of racemic fac-[Os( L1)₃](PF₆)₂ (monoclinic, C2/c, Z = 8) and [Os(bipy)₃](PF₆)₂ (where bipy = 2,2' -bipyridine) shows minimal structural variations, but differences are observed in the photophysical and electrochemical properties of the respective compounds. Luminescence emissions from Os^II complexes of L1 are typically lower in energy, with shorter lifetimes and lower quantum yields than their bipy analogues, whilst metal-centred oxidation processes are more facile due to the enhanced π-donor ability of L1. The key relationships between these parameters are discussed. Finally, though challenged by (i) the low reactivity of many osmium precursors and (ii) the irreversible formation of competing side products, the synthesis and purification of the heterobimetallic triple-stranded helicate HHH-[OsLu( L2)₃](CF₃SO₃)₅ has been realised, in which L2 is a segmental ligand containing the same bidentate unit as that found in L1 further connected to a tridentate binding site adapted for complexing Ln^III. Its solid-state structure has been established by X-ray crystallography (triclinic, P1^-, Z = 2).

The opposite orientation of the ester spacers in the rodlike ligands L 4^C12 (benzimidazole-OOC-phenyl) and L 5^C12 (benzimidazole-COO-phenyl) drastically changes the electronic structure of the aromatic systems, without affecting their meridional tricoordination to trivalent lanthanides, Ln^III, and their thermotropic liquid crystalline (i.e., mesomorphic) behaviors. However, the rich mesomorphism exhibited by the complexes [Ln(L 4^C12)(NO₃)₃] (Ln=La-Lu) vanishes in [Ln(L 5^C12)(NO₃)₃], despite superimposable molecular structures and comparable photophysical properties. Density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependant DFT calculations performed in the gas phase show that the inversion of the ester spacers has considerable effects on the electronic structure and polarization of the aromatic groups along the strands, which control residual intermolecular interactions responsible for the formation of thermotropic liquid-crystalline phases. As a rule of thumb, an alternation of electron-poor and electron-rich aromatic rings favors intermolecular interactions between the rigid cores and consequently mesomorphism, a situation encountered for L 4^C12, L 5^C12, [Ln(L 4^C12)(NO₃)₃], but not for [Ln(L 5^C12)(NO₃)₃]. The intercalation of an additional electron-rich diphenol ring on going from [Ln(L 5^C12)(NO₃)₃] to [Ln(L 6^C12)(NO₃)₃] restores mesomorphism despite an unfavorable orientation of the ester spacers, in agreement with our simple predictive model.

Inert and optically active pseudo-octahedral Cr^IIIN₆ and Ru^IIN₆ chromophores have been incorporated by self-assembly into heterobimetallic triple-stranded helicates HHH-[CrLnL₃]⁶⁺ and HHH-[RuLnL₃]⁵⁺. The crystal structures of [CrLnL₃](CF₃SO₃)₆ (Ln=Nd, Eu, Yb, Lu) and [RuLnL₃](CF₃SO₃)₅ (Ln=Eu, Lu) demonstrate that the helical structure can accommodate metal ions of different sizes, without sizeable change in the intermetallic M^…Ln distances. These systems are ideally suited for unravelling the molecular factors affecting the intermetallic nd→4f communication. Visible irradiation of the Cr^IIIN₆ and Ru^IIN₆ chromophores in HHH-[MLnL₃]^5/6+ (Ln=Nd, Yb, Er; M=Cr, Ru) eventually produces lanthanide-based near infrared (NIR) emission, after directional energy migration within the complexes. Depending on the kinetic regime associated with each specific d-f pair, the NIR luminescence decay times can be tuned from micro- to milliseconds. The origin of this effect, together with its rational control for programming optical functions in discrete heterobimetallic entities, are discussed.

The unsymmetrical tridentate benzimidazole–pyridine–carboxamide units in ligands L1–L4 react with trivalent lanthanides, Ln^III, to give the nine-co-ordinate triple-helical complexes [Ln(Li)₃]³⁺ (i=1–4) existing as mixtures of C₃-symmetrical facial and C₁-symmetrical meridional isomers. Although the β₁₃ formation constants are 3–4 orders of magnitude smaller for these complexes than those found for the D₃-symmetrical analogues [Ln(Li)₃]³⁺ (i=5–6) with symmetrical ligands, their formation at the millimolar scale is quantitative and the emission quantum yield of [Eu(L2)₃]³⁺ is significantly larger. The fac-[Ln(Li)₃]³⁺↔mer-[Ln(Li)₃]³⁺ (i =1–4) isomerisation process in acetonitrile is slow enough for Ln=Lu^III to be quantified by ¹H NMR below room temperature. The separation of enthalpic and entropic contributions shows that the distribution of the facial and meridional isomers can be tuned by the judicious peripheral substitution of the ligands affecting the interstrand interactions. Molecular mechanics (MM) calculations suggest that one supplementary interstrand -stacking interaction stabilises the meridional isomers, while the facial isomers benefit from more favourable electrostatic contributions. As a result of the mixture of facial and meridional isomers in solution, we were unable to obtain single crystals of 13 complexes, but the X-ray crystal structures of their nine-co-ordinate precursors [Eu(L1)₂(CF₃SO₃)₂(H₂O)](CF₃SO₃)(C₃H₅N)₂(H₂O) ( 6, C₄₅H₅₄EuF₉N₁₀O₁₃S₃, monoclinic, P2₁/c, Z=4) and [Eu(L4)₂(CF₃SO₃)₂(H₂O)](CF₃SO₃)(C₄H₄O)_1.5 ( 7, C₅₁H₆₆EuF₉N₈O_15.5S₃, triclinic, P, Z=2) provide crucial structural information on the binding mode of the unsymmetrical tridentate ligands.

Unsymmetrical substituted bidentate benzimidazol-2-ylpyridine ligands L2 and L3 react with [Ru(dmso)₄Cl₂] in ethanol to give statistical 1:3 mixtures of fac-[Ru(Li)₃]²⁺ and mer-[Ru(Li)₃]²⁺ (i=2, 3; ΔGΘ_{isomerisation}=-2.7 kJ mol^-1). In more polar solvents (acetonitrile, methanol), the free energy of the facial ↔ meridional isomerisation process favours mer-[Ru(Li)₃]²⁺, which is the only isomer observed in solution at the equilibrium (ΔGΘ_{isomerisation}≤-11.4 kJ mol^-1). Since the latter process takes several days for [Ru(L2)₃]²⁺, fac-[Ru(L2)₃]²⁺ and mer-[Ru(L2)₃]²⁺ have been separated by chromatography, but the 28-fold increase in velocity observed for [Ru(L3)₃]²⁺ provides only mer-[Ru(L3)₃](ClO₄)₂ after chromatography (RuC₆₀H₅₁N₉O₈Cl₂, monoclinic, P2₁/n, Z=4). The facial isomer can be stabilised when an appended tridentate binding unit, connected at the 5-position of the benzimidazol-2-ylpyridine unit in ligand L1, interacts with nine-coordinate lanthanides(III). The free energy of the facial↔meridional isomerisation is reversed (ΔGΘ_{isomerisation}≥11.4 kJ mol^-1), and the Ru — N bonds are labile enough to allow the quantitative thermodynamic self-assembly of HHH-[RuLu(L1)₃]⁵⁺ within hours ([RuLu(L1)₃](CF₃SO₃)_4.5Cl_0.5(CH₃OH)_2.5: RuLuC₁₀₆H₁₀₉Cl_0.5N₂₁O₁₉S_4.5F_13.5, triclinic, P, Z=2). Electrochemical and photophysical studies show that the benzimidazol-2-ylpyridine units in L1-L3 display similar π-acceptor properties to, but stronger π-donor properties than, those found in 2,2'-bipyridine. This shifts the intraligand π→π^* and the MLCT transitions toward lower energies in the pseudo-octahedral [Ru(Li)₃]²⁺ (i=2, 3) chromophores. The concomitant short lifetime of the ³MLCT excited state points to efficient, thermally activated quenching via low-energy Ru-centred d-d states, a limitation which is partially overcome by mechanical coupling in HHH-[RuLu(L1)₃]⁵⁺.

The combination of one contact and three pseudo-contact contributions to the NMR hyperfine paramagnetic shift of each proton in the triple-stranded helicates [Ln₃(L1)₃]⁹⁺(Ln = Ce–Yb except Pm, Gd) produce intractable ¹H NMR spectra whose assignment is limited by the large electronic contribution to the nuclear relaxation processes. The detailed analysis of the NMR spectra for the diamagnetic complexes [Ln₃(L1)₃]⁹⁺(Ln = La, Lu, Y) shows that the triple-helical structure found in the solid state is maintained in solution. Extension of the classical one-nucleus crystal-field dependent model-free method for paramagnetic D₃-symmetrical homotrimetallic lanthanide complexes possessing two different metallic sites (i.e. two second-rank crystal-field parameters: B20^central and B20^terminal) allows (i) the complete interpretation of the paramagnetic signals for Ln = Ce–Yb and (ii) the detection of a concomitant abrupt change of the contact terms F_i and of the pseudo-contact terms S_i=B20^centralG1i+B20^terminal(G2i+G3i) occurring near the middle of the lanthanide series. The derivation and application of a novel three-nuclei crystal-field independent method eventually demonstrates that the helicates [Ln₃(L1)₃]⁹⁺ adopt a single D₃-symmetrical structure along the complete lanthanide series in solution, which ascribes the discontinuity observed for S_i to a concomitant decrease of the two crystal-field parameters. Comparison with structural models is limited by the extreme sensitivity of the structural factors C_ikl and D_ikl to minor geometrical variations affecting the wrapping of the ligand strands, but calculations of the geometrical factors Gmi(m= 1–3) for [Ln₃(L1)₃]⁹⁺ in solution confirm the formation of a regular triple-helical structure. Generalization of this novel three-nuclei method for addressing the solution structure of rhombic lanthanide complexes is discussed.

The hydrolysis of terminal ^tbutyl-ester groups provides the novel nonadentate podand tris{2-[N-methylcarbamoyl-(6-carboxypyridine-2)-ethyl]amine} (L13) which exists as a mixture of slowly interconverting conformers in solution. At pH = 8.0 in water, its deprotonated form [L13 − 3H]^3- reacts with Ln(ClO₄)₃ to give the poorly soluble and stable podates [Ln(L13 − 3H)] (log(β₁₁₀) = 6.7−7.0, Ln = La−Lu). The isolated complexes [Ln(L13 − 3H)](H₂O)₇ (Ln = Eu, 8; Tb, 9; Lu, 10) are isostructural, and their crystal structures show Ln(III) to be nine-coordinate in a pseudotricapped trigonal prismatic site defined by the donor atoms of the three helically wrapped tridentate binding units of L13. The Ln−O(carboxamide) bonds are only marginally longer than the Ln−O(carboxylate) bonds in [Ln(L13 − 3H)], thus producing a regular triple helix around Ln(III) which reverses its screw direction within the covalent Me−TREN tripod. High-resolution emission spectroscopy demonstrates that (i) the replacement of terminal carboxamides with carboxylates induces only minor electronic changes for the metallic site, (ii) the solid-state structure is maintained in water, and (iii) the metal in the podate is efficiently protected from interactions with solvent molecules. The absolute quantum yields obtained for [Eu(L13 − 3H)] ( Φ^tot_Eu = 1.8 × 10^-3) and [Tb(L13 − 3H)] ( Φ^tot_Eu = 8.9 × 10^-3) in water remain modest and strongly contrast with that obtained for the lanthanide luminescence step (Φ^Eu = 0.28). Detailed photophysical studies assign this discrepancy to the small energy gap between the ligand-centered singlet (¹ππ*) and triplet (³ππ*) states which limits the efficiency of the intersystem crossing process. Theoretical TDDFT calculations suggest that the connection of a carboxylate group to the central pyridine ring prevents the sizable stabilization of the triplet state required for an efficient sensitization process. The thermodynamic and electronic origins of the advantages (stability, lanthanide quantum yield) and drawbacks (solubility, sensitization) brought by the “carboxylate effect” in lanthanide complexes are evaluated for programming predetermined properties in functional devices.

Variable-temperature ¹H and ¹³C NMR measurements of the D₃-symmetrical triple-helical complexes [Ln(L1-2H)₃]^3- (L1 = pyridine-2,6-dicarboxylic acid; Ln = La−Lu) show evidence of dynamic intermolecular ligand-exchange processes whose activation energies depend on the size of the metal ion. At 298 K, the use of diastereotopic probes in [Ln(L3-2H)₃]^3- (L3 = 4-ethyl-pyridine-2,6-dicarboxylic acid) shows that fast intramolecular P ↔ M interconversion between the helical enantiomers occurs on the NMR time scale. Detailed analyses of the paramagnetic NMR hyperfine shifts according to crystal-field independent techniques demonstrate the existence of two different helical structures, one for large lanthanides (Ln = La−Eu) and one for small lanthanides (Ln = Tb−Lu), in complete contrast with the isostructurality proposed 25 years ago. A careful reconsideration of the original crystal-field-dependent analysis shows that an abrupt variation of the axial crystal-field parameter A₂⁰²> parallels the structural change leading to some accidental compensation effects that prevent the detection of structural variations according to the classical one-nucleus method. Crystal structures in the solid state and density functional theory calculations in the gas phase provide structural models that rationalize the paramagnetic NMR data. A regular triple-helical structure is found for small lanthanides (Ln = Tb−Lu) in which the terdentate chelating ligands are rigidly tricoordinated to the metals. A flexible and distorted structure is evidenced for Ln = La−Eu in which the central pyridine rings interact poorly with the metal ion. The origin of the simultaneous variation of structural parameters and crystal-field and hyperfine constants near the middle of the lanthanide series is discussed together with the use of crystal-field-independent techniques for the interpretation of paramagnetic NMR spectra in axial lanthanide complexes.

Lipophilic linear semirigid side arms containing two or three successive phenyl rings separated by carboxylate spacers have been connected to the 5 or 6 positions of bent aromatic terdentate 2,6-bis(benzimidazol-2-yl)pyridine binding units to give extended V-shaped (L11) and I-shaped receptors (L12, L12b, and L13). The carboxylate spacers limit the flexibility of the side arms and provide crossed arrangements of the successive aromatic rings in the crystal structure of L12b (C₆₃H₆₁N₅O₁₀; triclinic, P_↑, Z = 2) in agreement with semiempirical calculations performed on optimized gas-phase geometries. Moreover, the carboxylate spacers in L11−L13 prevent efficient electronic delocalization between the connected aromatic rings and act as weak π acceptors producing a slight increase of the energy of the ¹ππ* and³ππ* levels centered on the terdentate binding unit. Intermolecular π-stacking interactions observed in the crystal of L12b are invoked to rationalize (i) the peculiar excimer emission ofL11 in the solid state and (ii) the rich and varied calamitic (I-shaped L12, L12b, and L13) and columnar (V-shaped L11) mesomorphism observed at high temperature. The Col_R mesophase detected for L11 demonstrates that V-shaped bent terdentate binding units are compatible with liquid-crystalline behavior. Complexation of L11 with lanthanide(III) produces I-shaped complexes [Ln(L11)(NO₃)₃] (Ln = La, Eu, Gd, Tb, and Lu) possessing a large axial anisometry as found in the crystal structure of [Lu(L11)(CF₃CO₂)₃(H₂O)] (LuC₈₁H₈₇N₅O₁₇F₉; triclinic, P_↑,Z = 2), which exists in the solid state as H-bonded dimers. No mesomorphism is detected for the complexes as a result of the large perpendicular expansion brought by the metallic coordination site, but the high energy of the ligand-centered ³ππ* prevents Eu(⁵D₀) → L11back transfer in the Eu(III) complex, which thus exhibits sizable red luminescence at room temperature, a crucial point for the design of luminescent materials.

A new synthetic strategy has been developed to introduce bent and rigid tridentate 2,6-bis(benzimidazol-2‘-yl)pyridine cores into rodlike ligands L11-17. The crystal structure of the nonmesogenic ligand L13 (C39H37N5O4, triclinic, P, Z = 2) shows the expected trans−trans conformation of the tridentate binding unit, which provides a linear arrangement of the semirigid aromatic sidearms. The crystal structure of the related mesogenic ligand L16 (C61H81N5O4, triclinic, P, Z = 2) demonstrates the fully extended conformation adopted by the lipophilic side chains, leading to a slightly helically twisted I-shaped molecule. A rich and varied mesomorphism results which can be combined with the simultaneous tuning of electronic and photophysical properties via a judicious choice of the spacers between the rigid central core and the semirigid lipophilic sidearms. Ligands L13,14 react with Ln(NO3)3·xH2O to give quantitatively and selectively the neutral 1:1 complexes [Ln(Li)(NO3)3] (Ln = La to Lu), which are stable in the solid state at room temperature but partially dissociate in acetonitrile to give the cationic species [Ln(Li)(NO3)2]+. The crystal structure of [Lu(L13)(NO3)3]·3CH3CN (30, LuC45H46N11O13, monoclinic, C2/c, Z = 8) reveals a U-shaped arrangement of the ligand strand arising from the cis−cis conformation of the coordinated tridentate binding unit. This drastic geometric change strongly affects the thermal behavior and the photophysical and electronic properties of the lipophilic complexes [Ln(L14)(NO3)3]. Particular attention has been focused on structure−properties relationships, which can be modulated by the size of the lanthanide metal ions.